CALL: 973-562-0100 | TEXT: 833-298-9684


Common Misconceptions About Adultery and Divorce

Common Misconceptions About Adultery and Divorce

Adultery can create significant turmoil in marriages and is often cited as a leading cause of divorce. Despite its common occurrence, there are still many misconceptions about how adultery influences divorce proceedings. Misunderstandings about the legal, financial, and emotional ramifications of infidelity can lead to confusion and unrealistic expectations for those navigating the complexities of divorce. This blog aims to debunk some of the most prevalent myths about adultery and divorce, providing clarity and insight for individuals facing these challenging situations. By understanding the realities of how adultery impacts divorce, couples can make more informed decisions and better manage the difficult journey ahead.

Misconception 1: Adultery Guarantees a Favorable Divorce Outcome

Many people believe that proving a spouse’s adultery will automatically result in a favorable divorce settlement for the wronged party. However, this is not necessarily the case. While adultery can impact divorce proceedings, particularly in terms of fault-based grounds for divorce, it does not guarantee a more advantageous outcome. In New Jersey, for instance, marital misconduct such as adultery is just one of many factors considered when determining issues like alimony, property division, and child custody. Courts prioritize equitable distribution and the best interests of the child over assigning blame. Therefore, while adultery may be a factor, it is not the sole determinant of the divorce outcome.

Misconception 2: Adultery Affects Child Custody Decisions

Another common misconception is that adultery will automatically affect child custody decisions. In reality, family courts are primarily concerned with the best interests of the child. Factors such as the child’s safety, stability, and overall well-being take precedence over the moral conduct of the parents. Unless the adultery directly impacts the child’s welfare—such as exposing the child to dangerous situations or significantly disrupting the child’s routine—it is unlikely to influence custody arrangements. Courts focus on parenting capabilities rather than personal behavior, meaning that even a spouse who has committed adultery can still be awarded custody if they are deemed to be a fit parent.

Misconception 3: Adultery Always Leads to Higher Alimony Payments

There is a widespread belief that adultery will result in higher alimony payments. However, this is not necessarily true. In New Jersey, alimony is determined based on various factors, including the length of the marriage, the standard of living during the marriage, the financial needs and abilities of both parties, and the contributions of each spouse.

While adultery can be considered when determining alimony, it is not the sole or primary factor. Courts aim to ensure that alimony awards are fair and equitable, focusing on the financial needs and capacities of both parties rather than punishing marital misconduct. Therefore, an adulterous spouse may not necessarily be required to pay more alimony than they would in a no-fault divorce.

Misconception 4: Adultery Must Be Proven with Concrete Evidence

Many people believe that they must have concrete evidence, such as photographs or eyewitness testimony, to prove adultery in divorce proceedings. While having clear evidence can strengthen a case, it is not always necessary to have irrefutable proof. Courts can accept circumstantial evidence, such as suspicious behavior, phone records, or financial transactions that suggest an affair. However, proving adultery can be challenging and may not always be worth the effort, especially if the divorce can proceed on no-fault grounds. Focusing on fault-based grounds can prolong the divorce process and increase legal costs without necessarily improving the final outcome.

Misconception 5: Adultery Always Leads to an At-Fault Divorce

While adultery can be grounds for an at-fault divorce, it is not the only option. Many states, including New Jersey, offer no-fault divorce options, which allow couples to dissolve their marriage without assigning blame to either party. In a no-fault divorce, spouses can cite irreconcilable differences or irretrievable breakdown of the marriage as the reason for the divorce.

Opting for a no-fault divorce can simplify and expedite the divorce process, reducing the need for contentious litigation over fault-based issues. This can be particularly beneficial in cases where both parties agree to end the marriage amicably and wish to avoid the emotional and financial toll of a fault-based divorce.

Misconception 6: Adultery Will Result in an Unequal Property Division

A common myth is that adultery will lead to an unequal division of marital property, favoring the wronged spouse. However, property division in divorce is generally governed by principles of equitable distribution. This means that assets are divided fairly, though not necessarily equally, based on various factors such as the length of the marriage, the contributions of each spouse, and their economic circumstances.

In New Jersey, marital misconduct like adultery does not typically influence property division unless it has directly impacted the couple’s finances. For example, if one spouse used marital assets to support an extramarital affair, the court might consider this when dividing property. However, the primary goal remains to achieve a fair distribution of assets based on the overall context of the marriage.

Misconception 7: Adultery Hastens the Divorce Process

Some people assume that citing adultery as grounds for divorce will speed up the process. However, this is often not the case. Fault-based divorces can be more time-consuming and complex than no-fault divorces because they require the wronged party to provide evidence and potentially undergo lengthy court proceedings.

No-fault divorces, on the other hand, typically proceed more quickly as they do not require proof of wrongdoing. Couples seeking a faster resolution may benefit from pursuing a no-fault divorce, which allows them to focus on resolving practical matters like property division and child custody without getting bogged down in proving fault.

Divorce Guidance for New Jersey Men and Fathers

Adultery and divorce are often surrounded by myths and misconceptions that can complicate an already difficult process. Understanding the realities of how adultery impacts divorce proceedings can help individuals make informed decisions and manage their expectations. While adultery can influence aspects of divorce such as alimony, property division, and child custody, it is not the sole determinant of the outcome.

For those navigating a divorce involving allegations of adultery, seeking the guidance of a divorce attorney is crucial. Divorce attorneys in New Jersey, particularly those with experience in handling complex and emotionally charged cases, can provide valuable support and representation. The Micklin Law Group, with offices in Nutley and Montclair, NJ, offers tailored legal services to help clients achieve fair and equitable divorce outcomes.

If you are facing a divorce and need assistance with issues related to adultery, contact The Micklin Law Group to schedule a consultation. Our knowledgeable attorneys are here to help you navigate the complexities of divorce and protect your rights and interests every step of the way. Schedule your consultation today.

Recent Blogs